Reviews

I (34F) had made a Reddit account years ago, but didn’t start using the app until last year when I needed some highly specific work advice. A friend recommended asking the appropriate highly specialized subreddit, and I did so. (Got some great advice! Stopped my panic attack in its tracks.) Since then, I started browsing more, and stumbled upon this podcast by way of the subreddit. I decided to give it a listen, as I liked the idea of having other people curate the best Reddit posts for me. The first episode I listened to included a story I had seen about an OP whose sister cut off her and her husband when her husband made a highly political “joke” that was actually a threat against OP’s sister. I’ll admit, my first thought was, “Oh no! This show is hosted by three dudes. No way they’re going to side with OP’s sister.” That’s when S, J, and J put me in my place. Their outrage towards OP and empathy for the sister forced me to confront my own preconceived sexist notions. I had to admit that I’d been wrong to jump to the conclusion that they would side with the “dude” in any given scenario. Every episode I listen to goes further to prove how empathetic, witty, intelligent, and open-minded these three guys are. It’s such a breath of fresh air in today’s (American) political climate. I didn’t know “people read Reddit” was a podcast genre, but I don’t see myself ever needing another show in that subcategory besides this one. S, J, and J offer incisive commentary, mixed with plenty of laughs. I also seriously appreciate that they don’t waste time trying to adjudicate whether the post is real or made up. It’s more fun that they react to everything as if it’s 100% real! Their reactions are hilarious (especially when Sean hears about a relationship with a sketchy age gap), and I appreciate the thoughtful discussions that ensue. So AITA for liking this show? Nah, NTA.

I (34F) had made a Reddit account years ago, but didn’t start using the app until last year when I needed some highly specific work advice. A friend recommended asking the appropriate highly specialized subreddit, and I did so. (Got some great advice! Stopped my panic attack in its tracks.) Since then, I started browsing more, and stumbled upon this podcast by way of the subreddit. I decided to give it a listen, as I liked the idea of having other people curate the best Reddit posts for me. The first episode I listened to included a story I had seen about an OP whose sister cut off her and her husband when her husband made a highly political “joke” that was actually a threat against OP’s sister. I’ll admit, my first thought was, “Oh no! This show is hosted by three dudes. No way they’re going to side with OP’s sister.” That’s when S, J, and J put me in my place. Their outrage towards OP and empathy for the sister forced me to confront my own preconceived sexist notions. I had to admit that I’d been wrong to jump to the conclusion that they would side with the “dude” in any given scenario. Every episode I listen to goes further to prove how empathetic, witty, intelligent, and open-minded these three guys are. It’s such a breath of fresh air in today’s (American) political climate. I didn’t know “people read Reddit” was a podcast genre, but I don’t see myself ever needing another show in that subcategory besides this one. S, J, and J offer incisive commentary, mixed with plenty of laughs. I also seriously appreciate that they don’t waste time trying to adjudicate whether the post is real or made up. It’s more fun that they react to everything as if it’s 100% real! Their reactions are hilarious (especially when Sean hears about a relationship with a sketchy age gap), and I appreciate the thoughtful discussions that ensue. So AITA for liking this show? Nah, NTA.

I found yall on TikTok after I was hooked on other Reddit reading podcasts. Yall are my second favorite!! John is my favorite!!! I love y’all’s takes and I appreciate y’all’s point of view even if I’ve heard the story from other podcasts. I’ve gone back and listened to all of them (yay OCD)!! Keep up the great content!! I’ll be a Patreon soon!!!

I really enjoy this podcast. I listen to it often. However I find myself fast forwarding quite a bit on a select few episodes. Sometimes the laughter makes it hard to listen to. It’s not a little laughter here and there but actual laughing fits where you can’t hear the content at all. So my only suggestion is to trim down those parts. I think it’s a great show and will continue to listen just some positive feedback that would make it even better.

But for sure listen. 😅 I didn’t learn quickly enough to not have these guys in my ear while running errands, taking walks, sitting at a restaurant for a just me meal and I feel like everyone around here thinks I’m crazy now. Fun, funny and punny. 😊

Entertaining while also being a refreshing beacon of light in this questionable world. Keep doing what you do.

Is it just me or is the editing not good in the latest episode? Otherwise I love listening to Reddit stories and these guys have quickly become a favorite group of mine

I really enjoy listening to the podcast. These guys have the best vibe and are so funny. I always go around with a big grin and try not to laugh out loud when I have this podcast in my headphones walking around in public.

Hello everyone (and the boys). I have binge watched every episode, and can’t wait for more. An absolute must watch, if you like to see three random dudes read random stories, without being sexist, or discriminatory. The guys give their honest opinions, and feed on each others answers to give you their opinions, which they’re absolutely not qualified to do, in any other capacity than being humans, and raised well. A thank you to their parents for raising them right. We also get to meet their wives, and other guests, and you get to know them like they’re your friends. An absolute “must watch”, or listen. They fill my solitude as a housewife with laughter, peek my interest, and give me an out for shaking my head at hopeless humans. If you have ever been stuck behind a car going 40 in a 70 zone, you can throw on some redditonwiki, and just know they would share your frustration. They are now my best buds I’ve never met. Also, there some shone/shain you’ll love to playfully annoy. Oh, and John: you’re a handsome short-king. When ever you sell your self short again, go look at that babe you won 🥇 Love from Norway 🇳🇴

One of my top two favorite podcasts! Yall make me laugh so hard and it makes my long trip to and from work so much more enjoyable!

Love this podcast, I have listen to the whole podcast from start to finish I have learned my lesson to not listen to this while I’m working at my bakery, I literally cannot contain my laughter. Also smut makes me blush way too hard apparently especially with John’s voices he does.

I love how John judge these people on their stories, the way he comment and take sides is very Filipino my dear 😂

I listen on the drive to work. Not sure this is appropriate as sometimes I laugh so much I cry.

One of the best podcasts there is! I listen to it everyday at work and it really helps get through the day when your day starts at 2:30 AM. Yall are great keep on keeping on!

I found your show through Tiktok a little over 2 years ago now. I watched your clips, then found you on Spotify when I started commuting 40 minutes to work! Now I'm in my final year of college and make sure I watch every episode when they are released Mondays and Fridays. When I graduate and get a "big girl job", I will definitely become a Patreon member!

I came across this show during one of the toughest and most vulnerable times in my life, and while I’m still working through it, this show has made a huge difference. It’s brought me hope and entertainment I didn’t even know I needed. Each host has a unique personality and perspective, but they all share a strong sense of decency and morality. It’s been both refreshing and eye-opening to learn so much about relationships, humanity, and making sound judgments from just one podcast.

Hey boys! I've been a listener for years and am slowly catching up with the newest episodes during work as I was overseas for a while. I work as a Deafblind support worker in Australia but am in the middle of changing jobs so this podcast helps me keep the anxiety beast at bay (I only play you in the car and not with my hearing clients - deafness and blindness is a spectrum!) I am currently listening to the episodes recorded during AAPI month and I gotta say that so many comments were about John and Sean "bullying" Josh as a white man. Well I'm fighting back! POC Unite! Overthrow the Whites! Asian Gang Forever! PS. Josh you're actually awesome for letting us have this bit, really means a lot to hear you laugh and stand on our side. Much love to you all and you'll have a rich rich in me always.

I’d give a million stars if I could. Absolutely love these humans. I will always recommend over any other Reddit based podcast. Thank you for being amazing humans John, Josh & Sean ❤️

You guys are the best! I just found you a week ago, and honestly listen to you 12 hrs a day since while running equipment at work. You guys make my day better, and I don’t know how I’ll get thru my days once I’ve binged every episode. I appreciate you all!

Recently discovered this podcast and absolutely love it! I’m having so much fun listening to the new episodes and working my way through the backlog. Sean (as an Irish descendant this is the only true spelling!), John, and Josh have the loveliest camaraderie. I love their perspectives and how their points of view are so diverse, yet they’re constantly supporting and hyping one another up. This podcast is a great escape from the real world for me, and I love how it’s so positive even when covering the craziest stories. The hosts have cultivated an amazing community and they’re so inclusive and open to learning. Highly recommend! Can’t wait to keep listening!

Trying to hard all the time to not blame folks for they mistakes and what we listening to a white man about problems

Hello handsome boys :) you guys are absolutely amazing, my girlfriend and I LOVE listening to your podcast - we usually listen when we are cooking or cleaning together. You always spark interesting conversations between us and pasSEANate discussions! My partner's birthday is coming up soon (18 of August!) it would mean the world if you could say HAPPY BIRTHDAY LILY on one of your episodes :) Hopefully one day we'll be able to become patreons and support you financially. Thank you for the amazing work you do with your podcast and for being so awesome! - Manta

Warning! Do not listen to this podcast.. in public. As you sit in the train (or wherever) with your headphones on, you will laugh, and people will look at you! But hey, people are just jealous that they aren’t listening to this funny and wholesome podcast. Let people look at you - it’s worth it! Seriously guys, great podcast! ❤️ And congratulations with 3 years of podcast! Looking forward to 3 more years! 😊❤️

Long time listener but find myself struggling lately. The amount of times Josh says like when speaking is distracting. Makes it hard to get through the episode. Sadly an unsubscribe for me as the show doesn’t feel the same lately.